11 Best Shaving Creams That Will Elevate Your Grooming Game

by Jay Kang | Updated on April 28th, 2023
shaving cream with straight razor and brush

Shaving is essential to any man’s grooming routine, so choosing the right shaving cream is important.

Whether you prefer a thick and creamy lather or a light and airy foam, we’ve covered you with our roundup of the best shaving creams for men.

Read on to find out which one is right for you!

Best Shaving Cream For Men Reviewed

Here are our suggestions for the top shaving creams to help you through the dizzying array of possibilities. 

1. Editor’s Choice & Blind Buy – MARLOWE No. 141 Shave Cream

MARLOWE No. 141 Shave Cream is the number one option for men looking to get the best shave possible. This 6 oz shaving cream is a natural alternative to gel, perfect for men and women. It features a proprietary MARLOWE M Blend of antioxidants, extracts, and other ingredients designed to nourish, smooth, and revitalize skin while providing a barrier to prep the face for a close shave.

This vegan, cruelty-free, and paraben-free shaving cream is designed to soothe and nourish skin while forming a barrier on the skin to prep the face for a close shave. It contains shea butter and coconut oil to moisturize, protect and soothe skin. It is also scented with a woody and citrus scent that is not overpowering.

Willow bark extract and green tea provide antioxidant benefits, while the essential oils of eucalyptus and peppermint create a thick, foamy lather to protect skin from razor burns.

In addition, it creates a slick and cushiony lather that offers great protection.

This has been my shaving cream for quite some time. I use Lather & wood ultra-soothing balm for my aftershave that leaves a nice barbershop scent but not overpowering. I also use several different types of cologne. This shaving cream does not have any overpowering scent and just does an amazing shop creating the perfect lather for my shaving needs.

Unless you don’t use any cologne or strongly scented aftershave, then you might not want this shaving cream because it doesn’t give a strong scent, just a very pleasant one.

The only issue I have is that I wish I could lather my face for a very long time, but just like staying in a bathtub too long can do more harm than good, it’s best to let it do what it does best.

I only use a very small amount of Marlowe, and it provides more than enough lather.

So, for the price, it’s a bargain. For scent, it’s a pleasant one. If you want the whole benefits of all the amazing ingredients this shaving cream has, this has to be a blind buy for anyone.

2. Best Overall Shaving Cream – Aveeno Therapeutic Shave Gel

Dermatologists have recommended Aveeno as a top skincare brand for over 65 years.

Our list’s top rank went to this thin gel because of its calming components and reasonable pricing. Men with dry skin will love the shaving gel Aveeno has produced by combining vitamin E, glycerin, and oatmeal. It uses aloe vera’s hydrating properties to create a moisturizing lotion that leaves skin feeling smooth and clean after shaving.

Along with being hydrating, the Aveeno Therapeutic Shave Gel also incorporates oatmeal, which has soothing characteristics, and moisturizing vitamin E, which the company claims can help prevent razor bumps. Additionally, Aveeno’s shaving gel is non-comedogenic, so it shouldn’t clog pores.

3. Best Thick Lather – Art of Shaving Sandalwood Shave Cream

The Art of Shaving Sandalwood Shave Cream is an ideal choice for anyone searching for a luxurious shaving experience.

The cream creates a rich, foamy lather that helps protect the skin from irritation by improving razor glide. It also softens the beard for a close and comfortable shave and contains natural essential oils with a subtle scent that won’t overpower.

Additionally, the cream is packed with botanical ingredients that hydrate and soften the beard hair for a smooth shave. All in all, it’s the perfect choice for anyone looking for an indulgent shaving experience.

The sandalwood scent is clean and light, making it an ideal choice for men who want a great shave without an overpowering fragrance.

4. Best Hydrating Shaving Cream –  Harry’s Shave

Harry’s Shave Cream is the perfect choice for men looking for a rich and creamy shaving cream that will leave their skin feeling smooth and hydrated. The thick formula is made with 12 natural oils and extracts that moisturize and refresh the skin, including marula oil and eucalyptus.

Essential oils of eucalyptus and mint cool and soothe the skin, while aloe vera helps to nourish. Harry’s Shave Cream helps the razor to glide effortlessly over the skin, ensuring a close and comfortable shave every time. With its reputation as one of the best shaving creams, Harry’s Shave Cream is well worth the investment.

Harry’s Shave Cream provides exceptional lubrication while cushioning your skin to enjoy a close and comfortable shave without irritation. With just one squirt of Harry’s Shave cream, you’ll be able to cover your entire face with a thick protective lather.

5. Best Natural Shaving Cream – Blu Atlas Shave Cream

For the ultimate luxury shaving experience, there’s Blu Atlas Shaving Cream. This rich and luxurious cream is formulated with natural ingredients and is designed to soothe irritation, reduce nicks and cuts, and help you get the closest shave possible.

It also helps to restore and moisturize your skin. It is made with 99% naturally based components. It’s perfect for sensitive skin and ready to use right out of the container. With a light and pleasant aroma, this shaving cream will help you get the best shave.

This Blu Atlas cream has a luxurious, rich finish and is of the highest caliber. It elevates your shaving experience by fusing bergamot, clary sage, and patchouli with the earthy aroma of the woods. This shaving cream will make your skin clean, smooth, and healthy because it is fortified with vitamin E.

Blu Atlas is perfect for people allergic to artificial substances because it only contains natural ingredients and neither sulfates nor parabens.

Dermatologists have also evaluated the products’ effectiveness and safety. We appreciate that they have the scientific evidence to support their claims for their products. Blu Atlas’ shaving cream does more than give you a close shave; it also leaves your face feeling smooth and moisturized.

6. Best for Ingrown Hairs – Bevel Shaving Cream

Bevel Shaving Cream is designed especially for men prone to razor bumps. This ultra-moisturizing shave cream is formulated with aloe vera, shea butter, and comfrey extract to help the Bevel Razor glide smoothly over the skin. It also helps to heal and regenerate the skin while protecting it from irritation. The unique blend of ingredients lifts and softens hair so you can achieve an effortless shave every time.

It’s also enriched with Aloe Vera and Vitamin E to soothe and nourish the skin while shaving. With an 89% rating from 800 Amazon reviews, Bevel Shaving Cream will put your best face forward.

Vitamin E is also added to tone skin and reduce razor bumps. It forms a protective barrier that prevents the razor from cutting too close to the skin. Plus, its creamy texture provides an extra layer of comfort and nourishment for a smooth and irritation-free shave.

7. Best Value – Cremo Original Shave Cream

The next product on our list is Cremo Original Shave Cream, known for its slick and smooth shaving experience.

Cremo is known for its slick and smooth shaving products, and its original formula allows your razor to glide effortlessly over the skin without nicks, cuts, or razor burns. With an almond-sized squeeze, you can create a thin lather that dramatically reduces irritation and gives you the closest, most comfortable shave. Cremo’s unique scent makes for a bright, fresh, and highly-enjoyable experience every time.

This shaving cream is made with aloe, allantoin, and a skin-harmonizing blend of papaya fruit extract, macadamia seed oil, olive leaf extract, and other natural oils that provide a slippery layer of protection between your razor and your skin. This shaving cream is also water-activated, so you only need a small amount to experience the full benefits of its moisturizing properties.

8. Best Shaving Cream for Sensitive Skin – Vanicream Shave Cream

Vanicream Shave Cream is the best shaving cream for those with sensitive skin. Its non-lathering formula has been specially designed to avoid common chemical irritants in ordinary shaving creams.

The protective barrier it creates between the razor and the skin helps to protect against burns and cuts. It’s also free from fragrances, alcohol, and parabens. Those with easily irritated or sensitive skin will find this shave cream ideal to use in their daily routine. It

it’s smooth, creamy, and moisturizing, allowing the razor to glide across the face without leaving it feeling dry or red. If you’re looking for a shaving cream specifically designed for sensitive skin, then Vanicream Shave Cream is your best bet.

9. Best Shaving Cream for MASSIVE Facial Hair – Proraso Shaving Cream

A company operating for over 70 years produces the Proraso Shaving Cream, a traditional type of cream. Due to the company’s extensive experience in the skincare industry, they developed a unique shaving cream for guys who enjoy the traditional shaving method.

It contains a mixture of glycerin, lactic acid, and menthol that lifts hair to the surface and lessens the possibility of ingrown hair. Proraso is targeted toward men. However, women have discovered that it works equally well on their skin.

A heavier shaving cream has apparent advantages. In addition to providing superior protection against nicks and cuts, it will also leave a thin film of moisture on your face that will keep your skin hydrated.

Straight razors are best with this thick shaving cream because of their thickness. We strongly advise against using a low-quality disposable razor with this shaving cream.

Proraso advises using a dime-sized amount of shaving cream at most. Customers can create a lather with their hands or a brush. Shaving cream should be whipped into a frothy film with water before being softly applied to your wet face.

10. Best Sandalwood – Taylor of Old Bond Street Sandalwood Shaving Cream Bowl

Look no further than Taylor of Old Bond Street Sandalwood Shaving Cream Bowl for a top-quality, luxurious shave. Established in 1854 during the reign of Queen Victoria, Taylor of Old Bond Street has been manufacturing quality products for over a century and a half.

I use this as I am traveling the world at the moment. Their shaving cream comes in a resealable bowl, so it does not need to carry an additional shave bowl or worry about the bottle squeezing out the cream. It’s resealable, which makes the shaving cream last longer. It has a classic sandalwood scent and creates a supremely slick lather to ensure a smooth shave with maximum protection against irritation and discomfort.

This classic fragrance has top notes of geranium, lavender, rosemary, and sandalwood. It has a rich consistency and creamy lather that will help soften your whiskers and provide a comfortable shave. The luscious sandalwood scent is sure to provide excellent lubrication that will protect your skin against irritation and discomfort.

Taylor of Old Bond Street Sandalwood Shaving Cream Bowl is a tried and trusted product with an irresistible sandalwood scent many men enjoy. It is enriched with moisturizing polymers to give users a smoother shave. In terms of performance, it provides ample lather and a close shave.

11. Most Luxurious – St. James Of London

St. James of London’s Mandarin & Patchouli Shave Cream is the perfect choice for a luxurious and comfortable shave. Its rich, creamy lather provides a smooth, cushioning effect on the skin, making it a great option for sensitive skin.

The exquisite top notes of Mandarin & Patchouli and key essential oils provide a pleasant aroma that refreshes you. The product is also made in small batches to ensure its quality and consistency, making it a popular choice among top-shelf grooming products. With its all-natural ingredients, St. James of London’s Mandarin & Patchouli Shave Cream is an excellent choice for the perfect shave.

How to Choose the Right Shaving Cream for You

Finding the perfect shaving cream for your needs can be a daunting task. With such wide varieties and brands, it’s hard to know which is right.

Consider the Ingredients

When considering what type of shaving cream to purchase, it is important to look at the ingredients. Natural ingredients such as coconut, avocado, almond, and stearic acid are nourishing and hydrating and can help to prevent ingrown hairs and skin irritation.

Vitamin E, aloe, and jojoba oil are also beneficial in shaving creams and can help to keep the skin hydrated and healthy. Look for a shaving cream that is easy to use and lathers quickly, as this will create a protective layer over the skin for a smoother shave.

If you’re prone to breakouts, you should look for a cream or gel that contains acne-fighting ingredients like salicylic acid. Remember, the main ingredient in most shaving creams is water, so make sure you choose one that is pH balanced to match your skin’s natural levels.

Take Personal Preference into Account

When it comes to choosing the right shaving cream for you, it’s important to take your personal preference into account. You may prefer a particular scent or want a more natural feel.

Different brands offer different scents and formulations, so it’s important to explore your options and find the one that best suits your needs. Additionally, if you have sensitive skin, make sure to look for products that are specifically formulated for people with sensitive skin.

Tips to Find the Best Shaving Cream for Your Skin Type

For men who want a good shave, it is important to find the best shaving cream that suits their skin type. Good shaving cream can make all the difference in a successful shave and help prevent irritation, razor burn, and other skin issues.

There are a few tips to remember to find the best product for your skin type. First, look for a rich lather, a high-quality product that can help protect your skin while you shave. Additionally, consider what type of product works best with your razor – gels often work better with electric razors, while foams or creams may pair better with manual blade razors. Our list mentioned above is catered toward safety and straight razors.

Finally, keep an eye out for ingredients like aloe and shea butter for added hydration and vitamins like Vitamin E, which can help tone and soothe your skin. With these tips in mind, you should be able to find the best shaving cream for your skin type.

Make the Final Decision

Once you have considered all the information and criteria, it’s time to decide. You can look for products specifically designed for sensitive skin or those with more aggressive ingredients if you’re looking for a close shave.

The key is finding something suitable for your needs that will help protect your skin from irritation and damage. Remember that the most expensive product isn’t necessarily the best – it’s about finding something that works for you. No matter what type of shaving cream you choose, make sure to use it regularly to get the best results.

Last update on 2024-04-14 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Affiliate Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links, which means I may receive a small commission, at no extra cost to you, if you make a purchase using these links.

Jay Kang

Just because i'm asian does not mean I don't need shaving. I always wanted to grow a beard when I was young, now I need to shave because hair growth for me is a problem. I'm going through what every man will and has gone through before.

A note to our visitors

This website has updated its privacy policy in compliance with changes to European Union data protection law, for all members globally. We’ve also updated our Privacy Policy to give you more information about your rights and responsibilities with respect to your privacy and personal information. Please read this to review the updates about which cookies we use and what information we collect on our site. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our updated privacy policy.