12 Best Aftershave for Men, Your Skin Type & Budget

by Jay Kang | Updated on April 6th, 2023
aftershave

Searching for the perfect aftershave to add the finishing touch to your grooming routine?


We’ve rounded up the best aftershaves that will keep your skin feeling smooth and refreshed.

Check out our list of must-have products for men’s grooming and find the perfect one for you.

Best aftershave for men

Based on the considerations mentioned above, we compiled our top picks. 

Cremo Cooling Post Shave Balm

Cremo Cooling Shave Cream is perfect for those who want a refreshing and invigorating post-shave experience.

This shave cream contains menthol to deliver an icy cold sensation and healing ingredients such as Shea Butter, Baobab Seed Oil, and Tamanu Seed Oil to help soothe razor irritation and keep your skin feeling clean and refreshed. Its unique blend of peppermint, menthol, and tea tree oil combines to create a crisp, cooling effect that leaves your skin feeling revitalized and ready for the day ahead.

Pros

  • Cooling formula with menthol helps to close pores and tighten skin
  • Soothes and cools the skin while protecting skin from shaving irritation, dryness, and razor burn
  • Soothing, moisturizing balm
  • Delivers an icy-cold sensation
  • Contains Shea Butter, Baobab Seed Oil, and Tamanu Seed Oil to help nourish the skin

Cons

  • It may not be suitable for those with sensitive skin
  • It may cause some irritation due to the menthol
  • Overpowering scent

Lather & wood ultra-soothing balm

The Lather & Wood Shaving Co.’s aftershave balm makes shaving more comfortable and painless. It aids in calming and soothing irritated skin brought on by shaving without stinging or bringing on inflammation. Additionally, it helps to lessen the likelihood of razor burn and gives your face a cooling and refreshing sensation after shaving.

As a result, this helps your skin look younger and feel more moisturized. As a plus, the moisturizing, non-greasy formula easily absorbs into the skin.  The item is suitable for all skin types, especially sensitive skin, and has the traditional sandalwood aroma.

This aftershave is what I use primarily when I am traveling. I opted for the barbershop scent to bring back some of my barbershop memories since I have been traveling overseas for many years. It is quite small, so if you’re planning on using this every day, you would need to refill pretty quickly.

I love the scent, and the creaminess of the aftershave helps when I do get a razor burn. The scent is not overwhelming when I do spray my cologne, leaving a hint of cleanliness and not contradicting the scent of any cologne if you use them. It has a lotion-like texture, and even though after-shave lotion tends to be more liquid, this feels like a normal lotion to moisturize.

The only thing that some people might be bothered by, or at least for those who have oily skin and love to touch their face constantly, is that it is a lotion, so you will have some stickiness to your face. But if you don’t touch your face, it truly feels like you have nothing on your face and feel refreshed by it.

Pros

  • Removes razor burn
  • Hydrates and moisturizes
  • Helps soothe skin irritations
  • Suitable for all skin types
  • Made from organic ingredients
  • Conveniently bottled in spray-style
  • Has elements that won’t dry out your skin

Cons

  • Sandalwood scent may not be appealing to some

Proraso After Shave for Lotion for Men

If you want sting-free comfort, the Proraso After Shave for Lotion for Men is the best lotion. This product, designed for men, contains menthol and eucalyptus oil. Witch hazel is added to help prevent razor burns and rashes. Additionally, a small amount of eucalyptus oil adds a pleasant aroma. To consistently achieve a close, smooth shave, use this aftershave in conjunction with Proraso’s Pre-Shave Cream and Proraso Shaving Cream.

These products are manufactured by an Italian company, Proraso, established in 1908. Proraso has been producing high-quality skincare products ever since.

Pros

  • Refreshing scent
  • Cruelty-free product
  • Gives instant aftershave relief
  • Does not contain parabens, minerals, or silicones

Cons

  • The scent may be too mild for others

Nivea Men Sensitive Post Shave Balm

The Nivea Men Sensitive Post Shave Balm is the best option for those who are new to aftershave balms and would like something affordable. It relieves razor burns and pimples and instantly calms and hydrates the skin after shaving, thanks to its lotion-like consistency.

NIVEA Men Sensitive Post Shave Balm is a unique and extra gentle formula specially developed for men with sensitive skin. It’s enriched with Vitamin E and natural, soothing Chamomile and Witch Hazel extracts to soothe and calm the skin after shaving.

The light formula is lightweight and non-greasy, leaving your skin feeling soft and refreshed. It’s also alcohol-free, so it won’t dry out your skin. Overall, this balm is an excellent choice for men with sensitive skin looking for a quick and easy solution to post-shave skin care.

Pros

  • Has fresh scent
  • Budget-friendly
  • Has a moisturizing effect
  • Can soothe razor burns and bumps

Cons

  • Bottle may easily break
  • Scent may be too subtle for some

The Art of Shaving After-Shave Balm

The Art of Shaving After-Shave Balm is created without alcohol. Hence, it does not dry out the skin and can sting when applied, unlike other common aftershaves. It also hydrates since it contains pure essential oils and shea butter.

On top of it, all of the ingredients in this after-shave balm have been dermatologically and professionally evaluated to be gentle enough for sensitive skin and readily absorbed without leaving a greasy residue. This is your best option if you want to splurge on aftershave balms.

Pros

  • Alcohol-free
  • Non-greasy
  • Works best for dry skin
  • Helps repair the skin’s elasticity
  • Dermatologically and professionally-tested
  • Comes in unscented, sandalwood, and lemon scent options

Cons

  • Expensive
  • Watery formula
  • Can cause stinging

Marlowe 144 After Shave Lotion

Marlowe After Shave Lotion is a great product for men looking for a post-shave remedy that nourishes their skin. This lotion is lightweight yet provides effective defense against irritation, with natural ingredients like willow bark and algae. It also contains super moisturizing Shea Butter and Coconut Oil, which helps to soothe dry skin.

And it’s 100% made in the USA and free of parabens and phthalates. Marlowe After Shave Lotion is an excellent choice for men looking for a high-quality post-shave product that will leave their skin feeling refreshed and cared for.

Pros

  • Lightly scented with a clean balance of aloe and citrus followed by a woody base.
  • Helps to fuel skin cell repair
  • Includes natural ingredients like Shea Butter & Coconut Oil to soothe your skin.
  • 100% made in the USA.
  • Paraben-free and Phthalate-free.
  • Reduces inflammation and soothes irritated skin from dull razors, shaving cream, dry skin, etc.

Cons

  • The unscented option is not available
  • Not suitable for sensitive skin types

Bevel After Shave Balm for Men

Manufactured by Bevel, this brand has established its name in the male grooming industry.  This aftershave balm eliminates ingrown hairs and razor bumps. It contains tea tree instead of alcohol. It also has witch hazel for soothing skin irritation caused by ingrown hairs. Exfoliating ingredients like lactic and salicylic acids are combined with soothing ingredients to soothe easily irritated skin.

The fact that the Restoring Balm has no potentially dangerous ingredients is even more remarkable. It does not contain any artificial ingredients, such as sulfates and parabens, to name a few. After shaving, apply a nickel’s worth after shaving and massage it into the skin anywhere you shave.

Pros

  • Has a moisturizing effect
  • Has skin exfoliation properties
  • Does not contain harmful chemicals
  • Free from sulfate, dyes, parabens and silicones

Cons

  • Expensive for its size

Baxter of California After Shave Balm

Baxter of California’s After Shave Balm is the perfect choice for anyone dealing with ingrown hairs. It works to help prevent in-grown hairs, leaving skin feeling refreshed and touchably soft.

It also relieves sensitivity after shaving with cooling extracts of aloe vera, exfoliates away pore-clogging debris, hydrates and nourishes skin as it combats the serious dryness caused by daily shaving, and contains salicylic acid to tackle those pesky clogged pores and free those ingrown hairs.

Baxter of California’s After Shave Balm is the perfect choice for preventing and treating ingrown hairs.

Pros

  • Alcohol-free, great scent, and soothing
  • Helps protect the skin from the visible signs of aging
  • Nourishing post-shave moisturizer for men with aloe and tea tree oil
  • Perfectly formulated cooling and soothing after-shave balm
  • No burning or redness
  • Therapeutic, Moisturizing Treatment with Calendula and Chamomile Extracts

Cons

  • Can be costly
  • It may not be suitable for sensitive skin

Ursa Major Aftershave Tonic

For those with oily skin, Ursa Major’s 4-in-1 Essential Face Tonic is an excellent choice of aftershave. This tonic contains aloe vera and witch hazel to soothe and moisturize skin, as well as lavender to reduce inflammation.

Ursa Major 4-in-1 Essential Face Tonic is a versatile product that cleans, exfoliates, soothes, and hydrates the skin. It features a built-in AHA/BHA exfoliating complex and is free of parabens and fragrances.

Used daily, it can help to dissolve dead skin, clear blocked pores, and combat blemishes, razor bumps, and ingrown hairs. After using this tonic, your skin will feel refreshed, firm, and alive. Overall, this is an excellent tonic that can help give your skin the boost it needs.

Additionally, it is enriched with peppermint and spearmint oils to provide a cooling sensation that helps to reduce redness. This product is also free from synthetic fragrances and parabens, making it ideal for those looking for a natural aftershave solution.

Pros

  • A 4-in-1 product that cleans, exfoliates soothes, and hydrates skin
  • Built-in AHA/BHA exfoliating complex
  • Removes oil and grime left behind by other skin products
  • Dissolves dead skin and clears blocked pores
  • Combats blemishes, razor bumps, and ingrown hairs
  • Paraben-free, fragrance-free, cruelty-free
  • Used daily for maximum results

Cons

  • Not suitable for sensitive skin types
  • It may cause irritation or redness in some users

Claus Porto Musgo After Shave Balm

Claus Porto’s After Shave Balm is the best-smelling aftershave on the market. It is enriched with shea butter and essential oils, which help to calm razor burn and leave your skin feeling hydrated and refreshed. This balm has a luxurious combination of fresh vetiver and eucalyptus and the warmth of vanilla and patchouli.

Not only does it smell amazing, but it also helps to reduce redness and irritation caused by shaving. It has a light, non-greasy formula that won’t clog pores, making it perfect for sensitive skin. Claus Porto’s After Shave Balm is an excellent choice for those looking for an aftershave that smells great and is gentle on the skin.

Pros

  • Soothes and repairs post-shave skin
  • Delicate emulsion scented with lavender and vetiver
  • Fast-absorbing balm enriched with shea butter and almond oil
  • Jojoba Oil helps calm the skin after shaving
  • Hydrates irritated skin
  • Top notes of patchouli, neroli, and bergamot
  • Heart notes of sandalwood and vanilla

Cons

  • Expensive

HERMÈS Terre d’Hermès After-Shave Balm

The product is designed to provide hydration and comfort to the skin, with a light and fluid formula that absorbs easily and soothes razor burn. It has a delightful Citrus scent that lingers on the skin and leaves it feeling nourished and delicately fragranced.

It’s light; the fluid texture is quickly absorbed, softening the hair and soothing razor burn.

I am a fan of their cologne, and it’s my go-to for hot, humid summer weather. It is enriched with the signature citrus scent of the Terre d’Hermès fragrance, providing an extra layer of luxury. Ideal for those looking to nourish their skin with a soft and comforting balm after a shave.

I’ve been using it for a few weeks now, and I can definitely say it works wonders. It’s non-greasy and absorbs quickly, leaving my skin feeling soft and refreshed. I would recommend this product to anyone looking for a soothing and moisturizing after-shave balm. It’s definitely worth the price!

This balm is made with ingredients such as Alcohol, Parfum (Fragrance), Aqua (Water), Limonene, and Ethylhexyl and provides hydration and comfort to the skin. It’s a great option for men looking for a soothing post-shave experience.

Pros

  • Provides hydration and comfort to the skin
  • Light, fluid formula easily absorbed
  • Soothes razor burn
  • Nourishes the skin delicately
  • Non-Greasy

Cons

  • Fragrance is not for everyone
  • Expensive

Fellow Barber Everyday Tonic

Fellow Barber’s Everyday Tonic is a high-quality aftershave that has been around for a decade. It is a great skin care product that lifts dirt, removes grease, tightens pores, and promotes healing. It also has a pleasant smell. It can be used on all parts of the body, making it an ideal aftershave soother.

The spray is easy to use; spray it onto your face and hair any time to degrease and refresh. As many barbers have adopted it, it is an excellent choice for those looking for something new. With its affordable price tag of $28, it is definitely worth trying out!

Pros

  • Lifts dirt, removes grease,
  • Tightens pores and promotes healing
  • Smells good
  • Can be used all over the body
  • High-Quality
  • Adopted by barbers

Cons

  • It can be a new experience for some
  • Expensive price tag

What are aftershave products?

Aftershave products were first developed as alcohol-based antiseptics to treat minor cuts and scrapes during the shaving process. Even though alcohol is effective at warding off infections, it has a drying effect on the skin and can cause a painful sting if splashed on freshly shaven flesh.

Thankfully, aftershaves have progressed greatly over time. You may now choose from various antibacterial gels, balms, and liquids that moisturize, exfoliate, and tone your skin.

Why you should use an aftershave?

Razor burn, inflammation, and ingrown hairs can easily damage the skin. After you’ve shaved, you should apply some aftershave to your skin. This cream eliminates microorganisms and helps soothe and repair skin after shaving, preventing these problems from occurring.

Moreover, it helps keep your skin supple and soft. In addition to protecting your skin from bacteria and leaving you smelling great, the best aftershave for men can also speed up healing any cuts you might have had while shaving. 

Different aftershaves are designed specifically to address a variety of different skin issues. Here are some of the benefits of using aftershave products.

Lessen skin sensitivity

If shaving makes your skin look noticeably redder than when you started, you could use some aloe vera. Aside from aloe vera’s anti-inflammatory qualities, it can also lessen skin redness.

Calm red, itchy skin

Many people find shaving to be an unpleasant experience. Having sensitive skin is one of these reasons. To avoid these unpleasant experiences, look for aftershaves with cooling components. Because of its potent anti-inflammatory effects, aloe vera should be a top candidate for your selection. Start with a little application before layering on the balm.

Helps ease razor burn

You’ve had a razor burn if you’ve ever broken out in a red rash just after shaving. Razor burn on the face can be particularly persistent. Make sure to cleanse the area. After you’ve washed the area and patted it dry instead of rubbing it, you can apply the aftershave. Apply it carefully.

Kills bacteria that cause acne

Many tiny cuts are made in your skin as you shave. The risk of infection increases if bacteria can penetrate the wounds. Use an aftershave with alcohol in it to kill bacteria on your skin. If these bacteria are not eliminated, your acne will worsen.  In other words, acne can be cured using compounds with antiseptic properties, such as tea tree oil and witch hazel.

Avoid ingrown hairs

Shaving increases the risk of ingrown hairs significantly. Uncomfortable ingrown hairs occur when your hair grows inward into your skin and is typically seen in those with coarse or curly hair. Aftershave creams are the solution if you experience this situation. These lotions add more moisture, which opens pores and prevents hair from curling inward.

Hydrates dry skin

You should choose a restorative aftershave that protects from the elements because dry skin results from a lack of moisture.

Which aftershave type should you use?

Considering the wide variety of aftershave products available, it’s important to consider what you’ll be using it for after you shave. Here are some common types of aftershave products to help you make your pick.

Lotions

Aftershave lotions have a creamy consistency and typically contain moisturizing elements; they are neither too watery nor too thick. Because they contain less alcohol than splashes, they’re great for persons with combination skin.

Splashes

Splashes almost have the same purpose as toner. Their formulas typically include caustic, disinfecting chemicals like witch hazel, and their formula is more liquid than balms and lotions. People who have oily skin benefit most from using splashes. However, although splashes leave a light, pleasant aroma, those with dry or sensitive skin should exercise caution because of the alcohol content.

Balms

For those who prefer a semi-solid aftershave, products like aftershave balms is an excellent choice. Balms are ideal for dry skin since they contain chemicals that hydrate and feed the skin, bringing it back to a healthy balance while soothing any irritations or sores. There are a variety of balms available that don’t include any alcohol, making them the most pleasant choice for people who are prone to cuts and nicks.

Bottomline

Avoid using aftershaves that include alcohol if you have sensitive skin; instead, look for alternatives that contain witch hazel. As a natural astringent, witch hazel is less drying and stinging than alcohol. It also reduces inflammation to calm inflamed skin.

Tea tree oil’s inherent astringent and antibacterial characteristics make it a good alternative for an aftershave. Aloe Vera can also be used to treat sore skin. Look for aftershaves with vitamin E or another hydrating oil for dry skin that needs more moisture.

Last update on 2024-05-19 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Affiliate Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links, which means I may receive a small commission, at no extra cost to you, if you make a purchase using these links.

Jay Kang

Just because i'm asian does not mean I don't need shaving. I always wanted to grow a beard when I was young, now I need to shave because hair growth for me is a problem. I'm going through what every man will and has gone through before.